Viewers Enjoyed Netflix Horror The Pale Blue Eye More Than Critics

Netflix’s The Pale Blue Eye flew under the radar when it was released last year. The film was a financial flop, and critics weren’t thrilled either. However, regular viewers appear to enjoy the movie more than it was credited for.

The Pale Blue Eye on Netflix

Christian Bale plays a detective in 1830, investigating a case with Edgar Allan Poe, played by Harry Melling (best known for Dudley Dursley from the Harry Potter movie series).

The Pale Blue Eye is based on a book of the same name, and it boasts a great cast, including Gillian Anderson, Timothy Spall, and Lucy Boynton. However, when the movie first came out, critics gave the movie a disappointing 63 percent rating on Rotten Tomatoes.

Horror and Detectives

While critics accepted that the movie had a good cast and gripping story, they criticized it for its poor script and execution. Others thought it was trying too hard to be dark and, in the process, lost its way. And some weren’t happy with how the mystery was wrapped up. But now, regular folks have a totally different take on the film. They’re calling it a masterpiece and one of the best ‘hidden gems’ of 2023, with Bale and Melling in particular generating praise.

Is it worth ignoring the critics’ opinions though? General viewers say The Pale Blue Eye is engaging, thrilling, and ‘real cinema’. One viewer even said to ignore the critics and stick with it, praising the movie for its solid plot, clear explanations, and conclusion that leaves no room for confusion. Give it a go if you’re bored next weekend!